Filled it with the auto shut off, it clicked off, I tried again since I knew it couldn't be full, and it quickly clicked off again. Registered on the gauge just below full. I have been driving on this 9 gal for a couple days now, and I'm currently sitting at a half tank, it has slowly dropped as I have drove, just like it normally would.
I've made an appointment with the dealership for tomorrow, since I've only had possession of this vehicle a month a two days... but considering canceling it. They don't want to give me a loaner, and have no set plan to fix it. I don't want to be without our new vehicle for days while they try part swaps to see if that fixes the problem.
Maybe I should wait for Dodge to release the TSB.